Quick answer

What USDA covers

Source: USDA FoodSafety.gov Cold Food Storage Chart, checked 2026-11-20. Freezer times are for quality.
Baked itemFridgeFreezer
Casseroles with eggs, after baking3 to 4 days2 to 3 months
Quiche with filling, after baking3 to 5 days2 to 3 months
Pumpkin or pecan pie, after baking3 to 4 days1 to 2 months
Custard and chiffon pie, after baking3 to 4 daysDo not freeze
Pizza, cooked3 to 4 days1 to 2 months

The chart lists baked items that contain eggs, custard or a cooked filling. It does not list bread, cookies, plain cakes or muffins, so we give no USDA time for them.

Where to keep what

Editorial; the fridge column follows USDA where the chart covers the item.
ItemCounterFridgeFreezer
Quiche or egg casseroleNo: perishableUSDA: 3 to 5 days (quiche), 3 to 4 days (casserole)USDA: 2 to 3 months
Pumpkin or pecan pieNo: perishableUSDA: 3 to 4 daysUSDA: 1 to 2 months
Custard or chiffon pieNo: perishableUSDA: 3 to 4 daysUSDA: do not freeze
Bread, cookies, plain cakesCheck the recipe or the makerNot covered by the chartNot covered by the chart
Cakes with cream or custard fillingNo: perishableCheck the recipe; custard pie is 3 to 4 days on the chartCheck the recipe

Store it in five steps

  1. Cool completely

    Wrapping warm baked goods traps steam.

  2. Wrap or box

    Use an airtight container or wrap; USDA says to wrap leftovers airtight.

  3. Refrigerate perishable items within 2 hours

    That includes pies with eggs or custard, and quiche.

  4. Label with the date

    See labels.

  5. Freeze for later

    Wrap well and freeze on the day you bake.

More gear for this

Search links on Amazon.com. We earn from qualifying purchases.

Thaw safely

USDA says safe ways to thaw include the refrigerator, cold water and the microwave, and not the counter (USDA FSIS, The Big Thaw). That page is about meat and poultry; for baked goods we have no USDA statement, so thaw egg- and custard-based bakes in the fridge, as the safe default. For bread, cookies and plain cakes, follow the recipe.

What the chart does not tell you

Most of what people bake is not in the USDA chart: bread, rolls, cookies, brownies and cakes without a perishable filling. We did not find a readable maker or baking-school page with storage times for those, so we give none. Follow the recipe's storage note, and when a recipe has no note, apply the 2-hour rule to anything with eggs, dairy or cooked fillings. Do not stretch a USDA time because a bake looks fine; USDA's times are limits, not minimums.

A practical habit: write the bake date on the container. If you are unsure about a plain bake's age, the date tells you, and when in doubt, throw it out.

Worked example: Thanksgiving pies

You bake a pumpkin pie on Tuesday for Thursday. USDA gives 3 to 4 days in the fridge for pumpkin pie, so it is within guidance until Friday or Saturday. Cool it, cover it and put it in the fridge within 2 hours. On Thursday, serve it, and put leftover slices back in the fridge within 2 hours. If the pie sits out for the afternoon, throw away the rest. If you want to freeze a slice, USDA gives 1 to 2 months for quality.

Sources: FoodSafety.gov, Cold Food Storage Chart; USDA FSIS, The Big Thaw; USDA FSIS, Leftovers and Food Safety. Checked 2026-11-20.