Quick answer

Diagram of four cast iron skillets by maker

Cast iron is bought once and cared for for years. Our seasoning guide covers the care; this page covers the choosing.

How we chose

Our four skillets

Everyday skillet

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 10.25 Inches

Who it suits: Cooks who want a stated oven, stove, grill and campfire pan from one maker.

Not for: Cooks who want a polished cooking surface; the listing does not describe one.

See it on Amazon.com

Everyday skillet

Victoria 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Who it suits: Cooks who want a stated weight (4.8 lb) and a long handle.

Not for: Anyone who wants US-made; the listing says Colombia.

See it on Amazon.com

Polished skillet

Field Company No.8 Cast Iron Skillet

Who it suits: Cooks who want the maker's polished surface and thinner sidewalls.

Not for: Cooks who want a heavier, thicker-walled pan; the maker describes thinner sidewalls.

See it on Amazon.com

Smooth-surface skillet

Stargazer 10.5-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Who it suits: Cooks who want a pan the maker pitches for cooking for two.

Not for: Cooks who need a stated weight or oven limit; neither is stated on the pages we read.

See it on Amazon.com

Checklist of specs to check on a cast iron skillet listing
Specs to check before buying.

Spec table

Specs checked 2026-11-20. Source link per cell; blanks are not stated by the maker or listing.
SpecLodge everyday skilletVictoria everyday skilletField Company polished skilletStargazer smooth-surface skillet
Listed size10.25 in10 in source10 ¼ in (maker); 8.75 in cooking surface (listing) source10.5 in
Pre-seasoned as statedPre-seasonedPre-seasoned with flaxseed oil (maker) sourcePre-seasoned (maker) sourceSeasoned
Made in (stated)USAColombiaUSA sourceUSA
Stovetop and oven as stated"Compatible with Oven, Stove, Grill & Campfire"Gas, electric, ceramic, induction, oven, grill, campfire (maker) sourcenot statednot stated
Weight (maker)not stated4.8 lb sourcenot statednot stated
Maker warranty statementnot statedMaker site banner: "Lifetime warranty" sourceLifetime guarantee (maker page) sourcenot stated

Cells with a link come from that maker page; the rest come from each product's amazon.com listing (linked in its card above). Blank cells are not stated there, so we do not fill them in.

Size table

Sizes as the listing or maker states them. Diameters are across the top; cooking surface is smaller.
SkilletListed sizeCooking surfaceWhat the maker says it suits
Lodge10.25 inNot statedNot stated
Victoria10 inNot stated"holds larger meals or sauces" (deeper vessel, maker)
Field Company No.810 ¼ in (maker)8.75 in (listing)"chicken, steak and baking" (listing)
Stargazer10.5 inNot stated"perfect when cooking for two" (maker)

Victoria's page also gives its overall size as 16.3 x 11 x 2.8 in including the handle and its weight as 4.8 lb. We found no weights on the other pages we could read, so compare them on the maker's page before ordering.

Care and seasoning

Every maker here describes the pan as seasoned. Seasoning is a layer of baked-on oil; Lodge's method is to bake oil on at 450 to 500 °F for an hour (Lodge, how to season, checked 2026-11-20). Smoke points vary by oil and brand, so ventilate. Our guide has the oil table and the steps.

  1. Read the maker's care page

    Soap, soaking, utensil and stovetop advice come from the maker.

  2. Check your cooktop

    Victoria states induction compatibility; the other pages we read do not. Check your own cooktop's manual.

  3. Check the warranty text

    Field Company's page describes a lifetime guarantee; Victoria's site banner says "lifetime warranty". Read the terms on the maker's page.